Deepa Roy and Victor Quimis
Introduction
Deepa V. Roy, 69, of Manhattan, and Victor Quimis, 40, of Queens, are accused of stealing the Kew Gardens Hills home of Renuka Bherwani — an elderly widow with dementia who was in hospice care — by forging her signature on a deed that transferred the property to the two of them for free. They were indicted in August 2025 in the first case ever brought under New York State’s deed theft law, which criminalized the conduct and gave the Attorney General original jurisdiction to prosecute it. In September 2026 the alleged partners turned on each other, with Roy suing Quimis and claiming he used the same playbook to steal her own home — and on November 5, 2026, the cases split for good: Quimis pleaded guilty to deed theft, the first conviction under the new law, while Roy maintained her innocence and is headed to trial.
Background Information
Bherwani bought the Kew Gardens Hills house in 1986 with her husband Mohan and lived there for nearly four decades; she began receiving in-home health care as dementia took hold, and was in hospice at the house at the end of her life. Around the time Mohan died in 2022, Roy began visiting the home, telling the health aides she was one of Mrs. Bherwani’s friends, according to the Attorney General’s office. Quimis was an accomplice in the scheme the office says followed: the two forged the widow’s signature on documents that transferred the home from her to themselves. Mrs. Bherwani died in June 2025, two months before the case was announced.
The Controversy or Incident That Led to Their Cancellation
Quimis pleaded guilty; Roy’s case continues. Quimis admitted the deed theft in a November 5, 2026 plea — the first conviction under New York’s deed-theft law — with sentencing set for January and up to four and a half years in prison at stake. Roy has pleaded not guilty and will stand trial in February.
According to the Attorney General’s investigation, the two forged Mrs. Bherwani’s signature on an October 2024 deed that transferred her home to them for free, notarized with a forged signature and an incorrectly dated stamp from a real Nassau County notary, and used her forged signature again on supporting paperwork. A second forged deed moved the property into Hunter Studios & Developer Corp., a corporation Quimis owned, and Quimis used it to take out a large mortgage on the home — after paying off the home’s remaining debts and liens, the fake owners netted over $300,000, officials said. The family discovered the theft in late 2024, when Bherwani’s son and daughter-in-law, sorting mail at the house, found a city agency letter addressed to Quimis congratulating him on becoming the “new owner.”
Quimis was arrested on August 4, 2025, and charged with grand larceny, offering a false instrument for filing, residential mortgage fraud, money laundering, criminal possession of a forged instrument and scheme to defraud; Roy faced the same charges and remained at large when Attorney General Letitia James announced the prosecutions on August 7, 2025. Both later pleaded not guilty after arraignment. The case was the first brought under the state’s new deed theft law.
The posture changed on November 5, 2026, when Quimis admitted Thursday in court to stealing the home of the dying widow — a guilty plea to deed theft that the Attorney General’s office announced as the first conviction under the new criminal law. The fake deeds will be vacated and the home will be returned to the family, James said; at Quimis’s January sentencing, where he faces up to four and a half years in prison on two counts of grand larceny, her office will also ask the court to void the fraudulent mortgage. “Deed theft is a malicious crime that robs families of their homes, their community, and their financial security,” James said. “Victor Quimis preyed on an elderly woman at the end of her life to steal the home she owned for nearly 40 years.” Her son Kamal Bherwani said: “Today’s conviction returns my mother’s home to her family and holds the man who stole it accountable.”
Public Reaction and Consequences
The case drew wide New York coverage as a milestone — the first test of the year-old statute against alleged deed thieves who officials said had long escaped justice through vague statutes. Senator Zellnor Myrie, a sponsor of the law, called deed theft “a cruel and insidious scam” that disproportionately harms older, lower-income and Black and brown homeowners. Kamal Bherwani, speaking when the indictments were announced, described the violation plainly: “My mother lived in that house for nearly forty years, and she was in hospice care in it when her home was stolen out from under her.”
The guilty plea resolved the pair’s cases in opposite directions. Roy, 69, has pleaded not guilty and will stand trial in February; she even claims to be a victim of Quimis herself, having filed a September lawsuit accusing him of stealing her own home — a Flushing investment property she values at $817,000 — with fake documents and a made-up notary stamp. Quimis’s plea, by contrast, closed the criminal question for him and left only the sentence.
Current Status
As of November 2026, Victor Quimis is a convicted deed thief awaiting a January sentencing on two counts of grand larceny, facing up to four and a half years in prison, with the deeds vacated, the home returned to the Bherwani family, and the Attorney General seeking to void the $552,500 mortgage taken on the property. Deepa Roy continues to fight the charges: she has pleaded not guilty, goes to trial in February, and her civil lawsuit against Quimis — claiming he stole her own home the same way — remains pending. The allegations against Roy are untested; she is presumed innocent unless and until proven guilty.
Impact on Their Career/Life
For Quimis, the plea converts the case that made him the first person charged under New York’s deed-theft law into the first person convicted under it — a distinction that follows him to a January sentencing with prison exposure, a stripped-away property interest, and a vacated mortgage scheme on his record. For Roy, the February trial is now also a referendum on her claimed victimhood: she will stand trial as an accused co-thief while suing the man she says deceived her, with her own $817,000 property and her liberty both at stake. The Bherwani family, which fought the case from a hospice bedside through the mother’s death in June 2025, gets the house back — the remedy the new statute was written to make possible.
Sources
- New York Post, “Fraudster convicted for stealing widow’s home,” November 6, 2026. source
- New York Attorney General, “Attorney General James Announces First Indictments Under New Deed Theft Law,” August 7, 2025. source
- Queens Eagle, “Two charged for stealing Kew Gardens Hills home from dying woman,” August 8, 2025. source
- ABC7 Eyewitness News, “2 in Queens are first to be prosecuted under New York’s new deed theft law,” August 7, 2025. source