Matthew Farwell

Matthew Farwell

Introduction

Matthew Farwell is a 40-year-old former Stoughton, Massachusetts police detective on trial in Boston federal court, charged with killing 23-year-old Sandra Birchmore β€” a woman he met when she was 12 and he was a volunteer instructor in the Stoughton Police Explorers youth program β€” and staging her February 2021 death to look like a suicide. Federal prosecutors allege Farwell sexually exploited Birchmore from the time she was 15 and strangled her in her Canton apartment on February 1, 2021, when she was roughly ten weeks pregnant and believed he was the father. After three days of jury selection, opening statements went ahead on October 9, 2026: prosecutor Torey Cummings told jurors Farwell “lulled her into feeling safe so that he could kill her,” while defense attorney Kimberly Stevens insisted Birchmore took her own life. Farwell has pleaded not guilty, faces life in prison on both counts, and maintains Birchmore killed herself. After four weeks of testimony from 50 witnesses, the defense rested its case on November 4 without Farwell taking the stand; closing arguments went ahead on the morning of November 6, 2026, and after roughly 14 hours of deliberation spread across three days β€” including a Monday deadlock note and a judge’s instruction to keep going β€” the jury convicted Farwell on both counts on November 10, 2026. He faces a mandatory life sentence at his February 3, 2027 sentencing.

Background Information

Farwell joined the Stoughton Police Department in March 2012 after serving with the Wellesley Police since 2008, and signed on as an instructor for Stoughton’s Explorers program β€” a cadet-style youth program he had participated in himself as a teenager, according to the Boston Globe. Birchmore, a law-enforcement-obsessed 12-year-old raised by her mother and grandmother, had enrolled in the program in the spring of 2010. Farwell’s twin brother, William Farwell, later joined the Stoughton force as well; the program’s longtime director was Officer Robert Devine. The department shut the Explorers program down after a 2016 internal probe found Devine lied during an investigation into harassment allegations connected to an affair. In April 2026, the state medical examiner’s office changed the official manner of Birchmore’s death to “undetermined” β€” stepping back from the original suicide ruling months before the trial.

The Controversy or Incident That Led to Their Cancellation

Convicted. On November 10, 2026, a federal jury found Matthew Farwell guilty of killing a witness or victim and of causing the death of Sandra Birchmore’s unborn child β€” counts that carry a mandatory sentence of life in prison. The account below is drawn from trial evidence, testimony and prosecutors’ claims as described in press coverage; Farwell’s suicide defense is included where documented.

Prosecutors allege the grooming began in a program built for children. On April 10, 2013, the 27-year-old Farwell allegedly had sex with 15-year-old Birchmore β€” below Massachusetts’ age of consent β€” one month before he married his wife, according to the arrest affidavit. At trial, Cummings told jurors Farwell sent the girl a Facebook friend request in 2012 and groomed her under the pretext of “tutoring” her at the library, texted her that the day he allegedly first had sex with her “was the best day of my life,” and described sexual fantasies including “domination, causing pain and rape.” Text messages the two exchanged years later became evidence: in 2019 exchanges cited by prosecutors, Farwell allegedly asked Birchmore what age she would pretend to be during role-play, smiled at her answer of “14,” and in February 2020 described pinning her down during sex; other records indicated he enjoyed choking her, prosecutors said.

By late 2020, prosecutors say, Farwell feared he was losing control of the relationship. Birchmore had drafted β€” but not sent β€” a text to Farwell’s wife disclosing the affair, learned the wife was pregnant with the couple’s third child, and began threatening to expose the relationship unless Farwell impregnated her, prosecutors allege. On December 28, 2020, Birchmore texted Farwell that she was pregnant; text messages from the next day suggested she feared he would hurt her when they met to discuss the child. Both believed Farwell was the father, though post-mortem DNA testing concluded he was not. At trial, Cummings said the ecstatic pregnancy text β€” Birchmore sent a poster reading “Congrats we are going to be parents” β€” was met with Farwell calling her “truly the worst person on the face of Earth,” before he made “a complete 180” in his final days: he asked for a key to her apartment and scoped out her closet and bathroom, a visit Birchmore texted a friend was “weird” on January 24, 2021, nine days before she died.

On the evening of February 1, 2021, Farwell texted Birchmore at 9:07 p.m. β€” “Are you still up. Ok to come by for a second” β€” and she replied at 9:10, “Yeah you can come say hi. You ok? Doors open when you get here,” according to the final messages shown to the jury. Moments later, at 9:14 p.m., surveillance cameras captured Farwell entering her Canton apartment building wearing a blue face mask β€” notably, prosecutors pointed out, for a man outspokenly against masking during COVID β€” and he left about an hour later. Cummings alleges the 6-foot-4 Farwell strangled the 5-foot Birchmore with a duffel-bag strap and staged the scene: positioning her body seated by the closet door with the strap looped around her neck and latched to the doorknob β€” “Eight days later, her dead body would be hung from that closet doorknob,” the prosecutor told jurors β€” and that he killed her the day before his wife gave birth to their third child to keep her quiet about the affair and the abuse.

On February 1, 2021, surveillance cameras captured Birchmore entering her apartment building’s elevator at 5:33 p.m.; Farwell left the building at 9:43 p.m. by earlier reporting, and his wife gave birth hours later. Birchmore’s phone recorded no movement after 9:40 p.m. She was found dead on February 4 after co-workers requested a wellness check, hanging from a doorknob in the same clothes she had worn before Farwell arrived. Local authorities ruled her death a suicide that May; Farwell, interviewed two days after the body was found, acknowledged visiting the apartment but said it was to deny paternity and end the relationship.

The case reopened in 2022. Farwell resigned from the Stoughton police on April 1, 2022; William Farwell resigned by August and Devine retired that month, all three denying allegations connected to Birchmore. A 19-month internal investigation released that September found the three officers had “inappropriate” relationships with Birchmore, violated “human decency,” and “should never have the privilege of serving any community as a police officer” again. In March 2024, Dr. Michael Baden β€” New York City’s former chief medical examiner β€” concluded Birchmore most likely died by strangulation, not hanging, citing a fractured hyoid bone rare in suicidal hangings. On August 28, 2024, a federal grand jury indicted Matthew Farwell, the only one of the three criminally charged.

Testimony began the week of October 12, 2026. On Wednesday, jurors were shown an ultrasound image of Birchmore’s unborn son and photographs of her cluttered Canton apartment β€” including one of the pregnancy ultrasound hanging on her refrigerator door, held up by a magnet, and a baby stroller box turned upside-down on the floor. Prosecutors told the jury Birchmore was at least eight months pregnant when she died, a claim that differs sharply from the earlier superseding indictment’s allegation of an eight-to-ten-week pregnancy; both figures remain prosecution allegations. On Tuesday, Cheryl Carlson, a former assistant principal at the Sharon elementary school where Birchmore worked as an instructional assistant, testified that she was so skeptical of the suicide ruling that she personally reached out to investigators: “It didn’t make sense to me. Because she was so excited to have that baby. It didn’t fit with her character.” Carlson said Birchmore had confided in her about fighting with the baby’s father but remained determined to have the child “no matter what,” and prosecutors told jurors Birchmore was “over the moon” about the pregnancy β€” even going back on her antidepressants as she prepared for the baby β€” testimony that cuts against the defense’s mental-health narrative.

The prosecution’s case-in-chief ran through 38 of the 50 witnesses the jury heard, including Birchmore’s friends, who testified she was excited to become a mother to a son and gave no sign of being suicidal, and Farwell’s twin brother William β€” a former Stoughton officer granted immunity in exchange for his testimony β€” who told jurors he had sex with Birchmore while on duty when she was an adult, that she seemed happy with no indication she planned to hurt herself, that Matthew told him he had wiped his cellphone after her death, and that fellow officers had conducted what he described as a cursory internal probe into the twins’ connection to her. The defense answered with 12 witnesses of its own: a digital forensics expert highlighted Birchmore’s suicide-related Google searches from the morning of her death β€” including “what color is the suicide ribbon?” β€” and forensic pathologist and former medical examiner Dr. Thomas Andrew testified it was “absolutely not” a homicide and that her injuries pointed to a suicide by hanging, citing a broken hyoid bone; under a heated cross-examination in which prosecutors catalogued what he had not been shown, Andrew β€” confronted with the ligature for the first time β€” testified that “seeing it today didn’t change squat.” Farwell himself told the judge on November 4 that he did not elect to testify, and the defense rested that afternoon.

Closing arguments went ahead on the morning of November 6, 2026. Boston federal prosecutor Brian Fogerty argued Farwell killed the pregnant Birchmore to “clean up his mess” because his years of abusing her as a teenager were about to be exposed: “He went to clean up the mess he had created years earlier… Clean up the mess by taking Sandra’s life.” Fogerty argued Farwell murdered Birchmore in her Canton apartment and staged it as a suicide to keep her from telling his wife about their years-long affair β€” which prosecutors say began with him sexually abusing her at 15 β€” on the day before Farwell’s wife gave birth to the couple’s third child, and recalled Farwell’s own words about the day he first had sex with her: “According to the defendant, this was the best day of his life. Sexually abusing a 15-year-old girl was this man’s single best day.” Fogerty also alleged Farwell groomed Birchmore from the Explorers program, creating what he called an “out of class connection” to lay the groundwork for the eventual abuse. Defense attorney Kimberly Stevens maintained Birchmore hanged herself after Farwell went to her apartment to break off the relationship, telling jurors Birchmore had built a “fantasy world” around the idea that Farwell would leave his wife and kids for her β€” a hope his twin Billy testified he personally shot down (“That’s not a good idea, that’s never going to happen,” per Stevens’ account of his testimony). Farwell β€” appearing in court in a black suit and white shirt β€” has pleaded not guilty to one count of killing a witness and one count of killing an unborn child; if convicted, he could face life in prison. Jurors began deliberating Friday afternoon.

The jury answered the question on November 10, 2026, its third day of deliberations. The panel of eight men and four women had reported itself deadlocked in a note Monday afternoon; on Tuesday morning the judge told the jurors to keep deliberating, and by around 2 p.m. they had resolved the impasse: guilty of killing a witness or victim, guilty of causing the death of an unborn child. The conviction carries a mandatory life sentence.

Dispatcher James Fitton’s testimony anchored the government’s timeline: he told the jury Farwell instructed him to “never talk about this again” after he relayed a tipster’s call claiming Farwell was having an affair with her friend β€” a call prosecutors said was the catalyst that pushed Farwell to kill Birchmore 13 days later. Farwell’s federal public defenders had filed a motion for an acquittal before the jury finished deliberating, arguing there was “no indication whatsoever” that he was about to be investigated or prosecuted federally; the jury convicted regardless. Sentencing is scheduled for February 3, 2027.

Public Reaction and Consequences

The case drew one of the largest jury pools Boston’s federal court had seen: 411 prospective jurors reported to the Moakley courthouse on October 6, 2026, to fill out questionnaires as Chief U.S. District Judge Denise Casper warned them to set aside heavy media coverage of the case. Prosecutors allege Farwell killed Birchmore because he “intended to prevent the communication about a federal offense to a federal officer” β€” her disclosure of years of sexual abuse that began when she was a minor. In October 2025, a superseding indictment added a charge under the federal unborn-children law, alleging Birchmore was eight to ten weeks pregnant with a baby boy when she died; that count carries a mandatory life sentence. In December 2025, the Justice Department announced it would not seek the death penalty. Birchmore’s family has also sued the Farwells, Devine, the town and the police department in a wrongful death suit now on hold until the criminal case ends. The verdict reading itself brought the case’s emotion into the open: people could be heard crying in the courtroom gallery, and Birchmore’s family members and friends hugged one another after the verdict was read, while Farwell stared straight ahead β€” his lawyer rubbed his back before he left the courtroom, remaining in custody as he has been since his arrest. U.S. Attorney for Massachusetts Leah Foley, whose office brought the federal case local prosecutors never filed, said in the minutes after the verdict: “Despite Mr. Farwell’s attempts to silence her, today her story is told.”

Current Status

As of November 10, 2026, Matthew Farwell stands convicted: a federal jury in Boston found him guilty on both counts he faced β€” killing a witness or victim and causing the death of an unborn child β€” after a nearly four-week trial with about 50 witnesses and roughly 14 hours of deliberation across three days, a span that included a Monday-afternoon deadlock note resolved when the judge instructed jurors to keep deliberating Tuesday morning; the verdict came by around 2 p.m. The killing-a-witness-or-victim count carries a mandatory sentence of death or life in prison; the Justice Department said in December 2025 it would not seek the death penalty, leaving life. U.S. District Judge Denise Casper, who has presided over the case, is scheduled to sentence Farwell on February 3, 2027; he has been held without bail at the Wyatt Detention Facility in Rhode Island since his August 2024 arrest. Farwell maintains his innocence of the killing β€” his defense argued Birchmore died by suicide and that he went to her apartment only to break off their relationship, as defense attorney Kimberly Stevens told the jury in her closing: “Matthew Farwell did not kill Sandra Birchmore. He did not.”

Impact on Their Career/Life

Farwell’s law-enforcement career ended in disgrace years before the trial: placed on administrative leave after Birchmore’s body was found, he resigned on April 1, 2022, has since been decertified and barred from working in law enforcement in Massachusetts, and his own department’s internal investigation concluded he should never again serve any community as a police officer. The conviction sends him to prison for the rest of his life, with the killing count alone mandating that sentence; Casper is scheduled to impose it on February 3, 2027. The case has also stained the institutions around him β€” the Explorers program is long gone, his twin brother and the program’s former director resigned or retired under denial of the same allegations, and trial testimony β€” including his twin’s account of a cursory internal probe of the twins’ connection to Birchmore β€” has now put the adequacy of the original police investigation before a federal jury.

Sources

  • New York Post, “Disgraced ex-cop killed Sandra Birchmore to ‘clean up his mess’ after years of abuse, affair: feds,” November 6, 2026 β€” source
  • New York Post, “Cop ’lulled’ Sandra Birchmore into false sense of safety before allegedly killing her, prosecutor claims as final texts revealed,” Oct. 9, 2026 β€” source
  • New York Post, “Haunting photos show pregnant Sandra Birchmore’s ultrasound β€” before she was allegedly killed,” Oct. 15, 2026 β€” source
  • New York Post, “Mass. cop faces trial in Sandra Birchmore case after she was ‘groomed starting at 12 β€” then killed’ when she got pregnant,” Oct. 9, 2026 β€” source
  • MassLive, “Sandra Birchmore case: Matthew Farwell trial starts Tuesday,” Oct. 2026 β€” source
  • Boston.com, “Matthew Farwell appears in court as potential jurors are questioned in the Sandra Birchmore case,” Oct. 8, 2026 β€” source
  • Boston 25 News, “Opening statements in Matthew Farwell trial expected to begin Friday,” Oct. 9, 2026 β€” source
  • CBS News Boston, “Matthew Farwell, ex-Stoughton police officer accused of killing Sandra Birchmore, seeks bail at hearing,” 2026 β€” source
  • New York Post, “Ex-cop charged with killing Sandra Birchmore faces verdict,” November 6, 2026 β€” source
  • U.S. Attorney’s Office, District of Massachusetts, “Former Massachusetts Police Officer Arrested in Connection with Murder of Young Woman,” August 28, 2024 β€” source
  • CNN, “Prosecutors say Matthew Farwell began grooming Sandra Birchmore when she was 15. Now she’s dead and he’s on trial,” October 9, 2026 β€” source
  • Boston 25 News, “Matthew Farwell trial (live updates): Closing arguments today after weeks of testimony,” November 6, 2026 β€” source
  • CBS News Boston, “Matthew Farwell’s defense rests case in Sandra Birchmore trial,” November 4, 2026 β€” source
  • New York Post, “Disgraced ex-cop Matthew Farwell found guilty of killing pregnant Sandra Birchmore,” November 10, 2026 β€” source
  • WBUR, “Jury finds Matthew Farwell guilty of killing Sandra Birchmore and unborn child,” November 10, 2026 β€” source
  • Boston.com, “Matthew Farwell found guilty in the deaths of Sandra Birchmore and her unborn baby,” November 10, 2026 β€” source
  • CNN (AP), “Ex-officer convicted of killing Sandra Birchmore to keep Massachusetts woman quiet about sex abuse,” November 10, 2026 β€” source
  • Los Angeles Magazine, “Matthew Farwell Found Guilty of Sandra Birchmore Murder,” November 10, 2026 β€” source
Page updated: November 10, 2026